DutchGirlinOregon asked: If you had $500,000 in disposable cash, what would you do, and why? (Purely from a financial point of view, putting aside the obvious benefits of being able to do what you like in your own home)
Conditions:
- You will only live here for three years, so you do have to deal with realtor fees, and reselling the place.
- $500,000 is the average house price
- Rent for the kind of home that would cost $500,000 is around $ 2500-3000 a month
- You would pay for the house or rent in cash. No mortgages, no loans, etc., so no interest payments.
- Property taxes would be around $5000 a year for owning such a home
- Housing prices are historically low, and your home may rsell for an extra $50,000 or so (or the market could remain depressed of course)
Thanks for your advice!
Hi Budhah,
The five year term you quoted is exactly what I’ve always been told, that it only becomes worth it at that point. But at the same time, like you said, the disposable cash makes the situation different. The ‘five year’ thing probably assumes that you will have a mortgage/loan that you are paying interest on. In addition, with houses being historically low, the house could be worth it in less than 5 years it seems…
Calculating realtor fees for purchase/sale, closing costs, property taxes, and maintenance (assuming we’re buying a loft for example), would leave us with around $420,000 to take out of it again after 3 years, and the property value may well have gone up in value by 50 to 100 by then, considering the market. Renting would cost us $108,000 or so. Seems like buying is much better, yet everyone tells me about the whole 5 year thing, that 3 years is just too short…
I’ll try to remember what people asked and answer it here:
Location: East Bay Area, CA (Berkeley, Oakland, Alameda, around there)
Income: Yes, enough to get decent tax deductions, however, I will continue to own my other 500K home in Oregon, so I think this second home will have no added tax benefit, but I don’t know the specifics of second home taxation. I suppose one could count as an investment property?
Money: Cash is 100% liquid, payable in cash, up front. Of course I could earn interest on the money if left untouched, so I suppose that works against the buying a home thing. With average growth of 7%, or 21% over three years, the home would go from 500K to 600K which might make me break even, which would obviously be 100% better than paying $3000 rent a month for three years…
PS: Not a school project lol, this is my actual situation, or at least it will be this summer, when I’ll need to decide.
Oh yeah, and we’re interested in a Loft apartment, in a ‘downtown’ type area with shops and such. Modern, maybe new warehouse conversion, that kind of thing.
Eileen